Skip to content

Insights

Vendors: Is Your Security Assessment Giving Customers What They Actually Need?

Key Takeaways:

  • Independent Assessments Matter: Customers need independently validated security documentation, not just self-reported questionnaires.
  • HITRUST Builds Trust: HITRUST certification demonstrates an organization’s commitment to security and provides independently assessed assurance.
  • Third-Party Reviews Are Essential: HITRUST requires annual independent assessments or verification of third parties with access to information or systems.
  • Certification Offers Added Value: HITRUST-certified vendors can help customers inherit applicable control scores and simplify their own certification efforts.

Suppose a security professional, manager, or leader at a SaaS provider, managed service provider, service organization, or vendor with access to customer information or systems sends a prospective customer security documentation upon request. The response after their review is a new list of questions:

  1. Does the scope of this documentation cover the services we are interested in?
  2. Who independently evaluated the controls assessed?
  3. What period does this documentation apply to?
  4. What responsibilities or commitments are still ours?

Maybe a penetration test has been provided of the company’s production environment, or a SOC 2 Type I report, or just a questionnaire that was sent over was already filled out. These could answer some questions, but it may not be exactly what the customer is looking for. The type of security documentation an organization has can vary greatly the type of follow-up questions they will receive, as well as the message they are sending about their security posture. The type of services offered, as well as the customers in a market, will determine the most suitable solution for how vendors can evaluate their current assurance process, support customer vendor-risk reviews, and explore HITRUST control inheritance.

The HITRUST Solution

For a vendor in the healthcare industry dealing with sensitive PHI, or who would potentially have access to information systems of customers in these areas, a HITRUST certification is going to be the “gold star” of compliance.

The first step in making sure documentation aligns with the needs of prospective customers is to identify the assurance the organization already has in place. One should ask: Is the current assurance independently assessed, or primarily self-reported?

For HITRUST validated assessments, the External Assessor must be a separate legal entity, and the assessor function must be independent of the business functions being assessed.

When providing a HITRUST certified assessment as documentation in these scenarios, an organization would be “practicing what they preach” inherently, no matter what level of assessment was achieved (e1, i1, or r2). For an organization to be HITRUST certified, they would need to undergo and successfully complete the external assessment process, along with proving that they manage their own third-party vendors accordingly.

HITRUST Third-Party Requirements

HITRUST has new relevant third-party vendor review requirements in the e1/i1 baseline to 14.05i1Organizational.3 [3207.0] published in HITRUST’s CSF v11.8.0 advisory that highlight the need for entities to review “…independent assessments or independent verifications of all third-parties with access to its information or information systems to determine compliance with contract provisions (e.g. security certification, attestation, audit report, or verification) at least annually.”

The key here is that the documentation being reviewed must be independently assessed and cannot be primarily self-reported, such as answering a questionnaire. If a questionnaire or inquiry is the only thing a vendor has, the customer seeking HITRUST certification would need to independently verify the claims made in these assessments at a minimum and document the observations appropriately to meet the compliance requirements.

As a vendor holding a HITRUST certification, a company’s customers would then be able to inherit that company’s control requirements’ scores in the future on any control requirements they would rely on them for (if they are defined as inheritable by HITRUST). If customers are seeking HITRUST certification down the line, or have one currently, it would be imperative for them to shop for a vendor that is currently HITRUST certified.

HITRUST Assurance

The most important question that an organization needs to fulfill to win the work will be: Can our customer use the assurance we provide to evaluate the security commitments relevant to this relationship?

If an organization’s customer is currently HITRUST certified, or is planning to seek certification in the near future, they will need to comply with the new independent assessment requirements previously mentioned, which means that the organization as a vendor will have to also. There are other external assessments that can provide similar assurance, such as SOC 2 and ISO 27001, but not with the ability to inherit and clearly define the scope and boundaries as would a HITRUST certification.

If you are a vendor exploring the idea of a HITRUST certification at any baseline (e1, i1, or r2), a SOC 2 examination, or an ISO 27001 assessment, be sure to visit our SOC & Technology Consulting page, and don’t hesitate to contact Dave Hammarberg, CPA, CFE, CISSP, GSEC, MCSE, CISA with further questions regarding our services.

About the Author

Brian Doheny

Brian joined McKonly & Asbury in 2022 and is a Supervisor with the firm. He is a member of the firm’s System and Organizational Controls (SOC) & Technology segment performing SOC 1, SOC 2, and SOC 3 engagements, as well as HITRUST assessments. In this role, Brian serves various industries including Software as a Service (SAAS), Managed Service Providers (MSP), and data centers. Brian is also a member of the firm’s Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) team.

Related Services

Contact

Subscribe to Our Newsletter